Research by University of Vermont scientists shows an unexpected new way to measure the nation's mood. Software created by
Dr. Peter Dodds and Dr. Chris Danforth of the University of Vermont, collects song lyrics, speeches and Twitter "tweets," zeroing in on the happiest and saddest days of the last few years. Today, Dr. Dobbs tells us about the "hedonometer," or Happiness Meter.
Comments [7]
This study is silly. If you're going to use language as data, how can you ignore context? Analyzing the use of the words "love" or "death" means nothing without a consideration of tone, the sentence itself, the sentences around that sentence, speaker/author intention etc etc. --i.e. all the things that give words meaning
Why use computers to crunch large numbers of something that ultimately gives no insight or false insight? You'd do better having 5 thoughtful, close readers sit down with these lyrics and give less objective analysis than plugging a bunch of vocabulary into a database and applying numbers to words.
Dr. Dodds is missing the point about all this harping on the individual words.
If the algorhythm is misunderstanding the words, how can the macro data be legitimate?
Sorry for posting twice, I thought I got bumped th first time for not being civil ;)
I'm a computer programmer and I would call this "algorithm" NOT SO SMART: the sentence "I killed my lover" would be balanced because it contains a positive and a negative word?
Dr. Dodds needs to check the word "context" in the dictionary. I know analysis of this sort is difficult with a computer but his attempt is a little pathetic.
Seriously! Has this "dr" ever heard of irony?
Death can me life and visa versa?
Of what significance is merely counting words without accounting for their context?
What about how the music might contradict the words, signalling irony?
Get real!
I'm a computer programmer and I would consider the "algorithm" here COMPLETELY IDIOTIC: So the sentence "I stabbed my lover" would be balanced, because it contains both a negative and positive word?
Dr. Dodds must be a borderline moron. Someone hand him a dictionary open to the word "context". Perhaps that part was too hard to handle, math wise...
Billie Jean is a HAPPY song???!!! It's about a woman confronting a guy that he knocked her up -- the guy is totally paranoid and scared that he's really the father. And it's in a minor key, all the way through. How about LISTENING to the song; READING the lyrics.
Leave a Comment
Register for your own account so you can vote on comments, save your favorites, and more. Learn more.
Please stay on topic, be civil, and be brief.
Email addresses are never displayed, but they are required to confirm your comments. Names are displayed with all comments. We reserve the right to edit any comments posted on this site. Please read the Comment Guidelines before posting. By leaving a comment, you agree to New York Public Radio's Privacy Policy and Terms Of Use.