Prince's hit song, "Kiss," is a beloved masterpiece- but could a cover top the original? In this Soundcheck Smackdown, we pit the original version against the 1988 Art of Noise/Tom Jones cover. Representing His Purpleness is Prince biographer Jason Draper, and making doves cry is music reporter Gary Burton.
Comments [23]
Hello-
This probably isn't the appropriate post to comment on, but I am DYING to know who played a strings rendition of Adagio Religioso about 7 days ago on the program.
I literally stopped my car, cranked up the volume, and got lost in my mind. I stayed to hear the name of the piece, but didn't quite get the name of the person behind it. It was very unique and hauntingly somber.
Does this ring any bells with anyone? I would be extremely appreciative if someone could point me in the right direction here. I've searched all over the web for versions of Adagio Religioso, but haven't found what I've been looking for, which was on this program. Thanks so much!
As a Prince fan I may be a little biased, but the Tom Jones version sounds as if his version should be considered a parody too! It kinda reminds me of what Pat Boone did with Little Richard songs. Tom Jones sounds as bad singing a Prince song as I could imagine Barry Marilow covering a Public Enemy song! Thanks to Soundcheck, I had to hear this horrible cover again! I'm just sayin'....
I enjoyed the Tom Jones cover the very first time I heard it. Which was during the smackdown. I'm a long time fan of Prince.
There was a situation of the "Hip" Hoppin on Hipocracy, your guest spoke as if he knew Prince did not have permission for his covers, Prince wouldn't do ttthhat!
Kiss!
I love both versions. The Art of Noise is fantastic and I'm a Prince fan but the thing that bothered me in the Tom Jones version was the change of the lyrics. Prince says,"Women, not girls, rule my world" and Tom Jones says, "Women and girls" -- a giant jump backwards for feminism, not too surprising from a guy like Tom Jones. Maybe jumping backwards is what he does when he says, "think I better dance now."
Oh--and in the comparison:
Prince is definitely the sexy seductive voice in a young girl's ear.
Tom Jones is too heavy-handed and loud. But I am certain that version works on stage. Prince's version is intended that humid dark hangout in your parents' basement, for saturday night and teenagers packed into a tight hot room.
I have already been crazy about "A House is Not a Home" by Burt Bacharach and Hal David. It was sung by Dionne Warwick and that's the version I grew up to love.
Most of my younger friends know the version by Luther Vandross. As far as they are concerned, it's "his" song. I can only sigh.
Prince. no question.
Funny hearing the two versions played side by side. If I didn't already know I think I would have likely guessed the TJ version was a classic original and the Prince version was an odd, kind of creepy cover.
I guess Prince doesn't need royalty money...
Thanks for revisiting these two songs. In my memory I remember loving the Art of Noise version, preferring it to the original. Hearing them together now I am astounded at much more more modern the Prince version sounds and well it holds up. What a great song from a musical genius and nut.
tom jones' is much funkier-Prince's is kind of weird though in a good way but not sexy. I think if people didn't know it was t.jones they would give his version more respect.
prince also wrote a lot of stuff,what the hell did T J ever write ?
I think Richard Cheese would do a better version of Kiss than Tom Jones
a lot of dudes just can't get into giving tom jones his do. men, get off your knee jerk reaction to have to put T J down. your girlfriends are safe,tom don't get around that much anymore. prince and T J can coexist. forget the jehova witness stuff,don't let that dude come "knockin" at your place.
I was an 80's dj for many years, 3 nights a week, every week, I can honestly say one of the top 5 requests every night I dj'd was Prince's Kiss
, and still today when I dj loft parties, I can guarantee to get the dancing going, by playing his version..
the Tom Jones version would have had people complaining and wanting the Prince version
I wish there was some way to blend the 2 - the Prince arrangement is hotter, fresher, newer, Tom Jones's vocal is hotter, fresher, newer, sexier....
A love child Kiss!
I like, and own, both! Each one is great in its own way.
Are you really saying that Tom Jones's version of "Kiss" is better because it's a hit at weddings (the worst music EVER played)?
as a child of the 80's Tom Jones RULES
Does the Art of Noise version count as a parody?
What's with this host? I'm not a big Prince fan, but what's with all the snarky "the anointed one" comments? I guess the host is just angry because he's a big nobody.
I almost drove my car off the side of the road laughing when I heard this. One of the best covers EVER.
Back in 1988, I actually bought the vinyl Art of Noise album with Tom Jones' spin on Kiss, and I played it fairly often.
That said, I've been major fan of Prince for many years, and I have to stand by my man on this one. Prince rules.
Leave a Comment
Register for your own account so you can vote on comments, save your favorites, and more. Learn more.
Please stay on topic, be civil, and be brief.
Email addresses are never displayed, but they are required to confirm your comments. Names are displayed with all comments. We reserve the right to edit any comments posted on this site. Please read the Comment Guidelines before posting. By leaving a comment, you agree to New York Public Radio's Privacy Policy and Terms Of Use.